The Pixel Empire
  • Home
    • "Back Issues" >
      • (#51-) July 2018 -
      • (#1-50) May 2012 - June 2018
    • 2023 - January - March
    • 2022 - October - December
    • 2022 - July - September
  • Features Index
    • Pixel Q&A
    • Landmark Levels
    • Pixel Hi-Score Duel
    • Pixel Timeout
    • Pixel Memories
    • Pixel Preview
  • Sony
    • PS5 reviews
    • PS4 reviews
    • PS3 reviews
    • PS2 reviews
    • PS reviews
    • PS Vita reviews
    • PSP reviews
  • SEGA
    • Dreamcast reviews
    • Saturn reviews
    • 32X reviews
    • Mega-CD reviews
    • Mega Drive reviews
    • Master System reviews
    • Game Gear reviews
  • Nintendo
    • Wii U reviews
    • Wii reviews
    • GameCube reviews
    • SNES reviews
    • NES reviews
    • DS reviews
    • Game Boy Advance reviews
    • Game Boy reviews
  • Microsoft
    • Xbox One reviews
    • Xbox 360 reviews
    • Xbox reviews
  • PC
    • PC (2000-) reviews
    • PC (1980-1999) reviews
  • Other (A-M)
    • Amstrad >
      • GX4000 reviews
      • CPC reviews
    • Atari >
      • Atari ST reviews
      • Atari 2600 reviews
    • Bandai >
      • WonderSwan reviews
    • Commodore >
      • Amiga reviews
      • Commodore 64 reviews
    • Mobile >
      • Android reviews
      • Java reviews
  • Other (N-Z)
    • NEC >
      • PC-FX reviews
      • PC Engine reviews
    • Panasonic >
      • 3DO reviews
    • Sinclair >
      • ZX Spectrum reviews
    • SNK >
      • Neo Geo reviews
    • Timlex >
      • Mega Duck reviews
  • U/O
    • Aftermarket & Unlicensed
    • Net Yaroze
    • Prototypes & Unreleased
  • Pixel Vault
    • Review Archive
    • About
    • Contributors
    • Contact
    • Like Films?
search The Pixel Empire

THE MISADVENTURES OF P.B. WINTERBOTTOM (X360)

Picture
Publisher: 2K Play.
Developer: The Odd Gentlemen. 
Released: February 2010.
Genre: Puzzle.
Other versions: PC.

Posted 10th January 2022.
By Tom Clare © 2022

A console-exclusive that launched on Microsoft’s super-successful Xbox Live Arcade range in 2010, The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom was indicative of the more creative output that blessed the line-up. Whilst a lot of XBLA’s most popular output comprised of older arcade games and rare console releases from earlier generations, Winterbottom was more in keeping with a push to give unusual indies a chance in the spotlight.

Winterbottom consists of 2D, static screen platform-puzzling. The titular lead has a thing for gobbling pies and levels consist of conundrums that require the consumption of all the aforementioned pastries, often in a specific order, to beat them. Many of the play mechanics bear resemblance to Braid, as the player engages in time-bending antics through the utilising of clones and portals. 
Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom Xbox 360 gameplay
Some levels allow the player multiple clones, to help grab those hard-to-reach pies
Winterbottom’s gameplay is reasonable. The main character controls adequately, with the ability to jump, glide and swat his stick, to begin with, before learning to clone his movements for short periods. This allows the player to combine past runs to solve problems. Clones can be used to activate switches at a given moment, whilst several of them can form a climbable tower. However, interfering with a clone’s path (be it through the activation of traps or the player altering their course) will cause them to disappear.

Straight off the bat, Winterbottom’s presentation is an unconditional triumph. Developers The Odd Gentlemen devised an unusual but highly effective visual style, somewhat akin to how you’d imagine Tim Burton might tackle a silent film. Clean and sharp characters mix with grubby, industrial, sepia-toned levels that putter along like old film reels. They make for an effective and pleasing juxtaposition. Elegant borders and some marvellously lyrical title cards emphasise the game’s early-cinema chic, whilst reinforcing its oddball style.
Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom Xbox 360 gameplay
Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom Xbox 360 gameplay
Some brief, wacky cut-scenes add to its charm and a level selection styled as film posters is a lovely touch. An impressive big band soundtrack proves a nice fit and, in addition to the game’s 50 main levels, there’s a bunch of bonus scenes that require the player to scoff all the pies against the clock.

Winterbottom is well designed, but it is neither as absorbing nor as enjoyable as something like Portal. Solutions rarely conjure the same sense of satisfaction, the same “eureka!” moments. Winterbottom is unlikely to be something you’ll play at length. Often solutions feel obscure and difficult to formulate, stressing a need for very specific methods and with timing windows that leave very little room for error. Inevitably, this leads to some frustrating platforming. The early levels are the most enjoyable, but it isn’t long before you’ll end up with puzzle-instigated fatigue, juggling a hoard of Winterbottom clones in challenges that feel increasingly messy and chaotic.
Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom Xbox 360 gameplay
Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom Xbox 360 gameplay
It isn’t a universal recommendation then, because there are many more enjoyable puzzler alternatives. It would be remiss not to compliment Winterbottom’s adept design, neat mechanics and gorgeous presentation, but it doesn’t generate the necessary magnetism to draw you back for more, longer-term. It’s likely that, whilst appreciating its creative style, only a minority of committed players will to stick around to see the credits roll.

Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom Xbox 360 title screen
VERDICT
"It would be remiss not to compliment Winterbottom’s adept design, neat mechanics and gorgeous presentation, but it doesn’t generate the necessary magnetism to draw you back for more, longer-term."

OVERALL: 6/10

Home

YouTube

Facebook

Twitter

Copyright © The Pixel Empire 2023